Sunday, November 15, 2026

She-Jesus

Your question: could a woman have ever had the sort of charisma embodied by Jesus? 
On the cover of I Promessi Sposi, that I am now rereading, there is an image of Lucia, in whom both the novel and the cover painting want us to see a sort of embodiment of innocence, of modesty, of virginity. Yet there is something about Lucia, particularly the jutting out of her right hip, a feature shared by most of the other images below, including the last image, that of Aphrodite herself, that lends these female images quite a bit of sensuousness, or voluptuousness, the very opposite, in fact, of what the images presumably are supposed to convey. The last of the images in your email shows the face of a woman, no longer young, no longer attractive. You also have an image of a veiled attractive woman. And your question is could a woman have ever had the magnetic power of Jesus. Not sure this question can be answered easily. The conventional view of Jesus is of someone fully spiritual, completely detached from sexuality. Could he be the same bodyless being if he were a woman?  Maybe—but only if he didn’t have the same physical attractiveness a woman has.  But here we get into a paradox: if, as a woman, he didn’t have the same physical attractiveness  associated with women, then he would have to be like the older woman in your set of images, who may have all sorts of positive features, spirituality included,  except  for the kind of voluptuousness  so prominent in the other images, starting with that of Lucia.  I sort of think that if Jesus showed up  in the guise of a plain, unsexy woman he would be unlikely to build up a following as large as that of the historical Jesus. The opposite would be true if Jesus showed up looking like Manzoni’s Lucia or any other of the more atttractive females in the images, including Aphrodite.  Heck, as a goddess of fertility and sexual love, Aphrodite would build up a huge following. Other female figures would qualify too—like the ladies of Lourdes or Fatima, but only if, as seems to be the case, their sexuality remains hidden. (It’s no accident, I think, that these ladies are given to us as sort of hazy children’s visions.)  To find what is probably a pretty significant piece of evidence that a woman-Jesus would have been able to attract as huge a following as Jesus himself has, we have to go back to when I was still a kid. In going to Sunday mass, like other boys and men I would enter the church through the side doors and walk to a pew in the front part of the nave, close to the altar. The girls and women would enter through the main entrance and settle in the back half of the nave.  I have no idea if this usage is still practiced.  Maybe not.  It’s not hard to see, though, why this custom started and was carried on for perhaps centuries. The town priest—the church authorities in general— were all too aware of the power of women to distract and to attract. They knew that had women been at the front and the men at the back,  it would not have been the eloquence  of the priest that attracted attention but the contours and backsides of the women in front.

So, would a woman-Jesus have been as effective? Still a big question 

No comments:

Post a Comment